Introduction
Cozy Horror? What's that?
The term "Cozy Horror" is a relatively recent phenomenon, with the earliest online mentions of cozy horror emerging within the past ten years. It is a subgenre of horror that provides a sense of comfort within the discomfort of being scared. The podcast, Books in the Freezer, reflects on cozy horror: "when you have horror, you can have all the spooky elements, but if you know, for example, you're going to have that happy ending, or low stakes … or even if the stakes are big, it's surrounded by humor, or a love interest, or things that kind of negate those big stakes1." Likewise, Nightmare Magazine posted an extensive article on cozy horror called "The H Word: Getting Cozy with Horror" in 2015. The article's writer, Jose Cruz, states that there are four key components to any media that would fall into the cozy horror subgenre.

They are as follows:
Familiarity
According to Cruz, "while many horror stories grapple with fear of the unknown, there are elements within and without the narrative of cozy horror stories that bring the work in question into a safer, more knowable realm, allowing for a sense of comfort to take hold2." This familiarity can come about in a variety of ways - rewatchability, setting, time frame, nostalgia, etc. Is this book or film something you engage with every year for halloween? Does it have pleasant memories associated with it for the reader? Are the main characters relatable and kind, despite everything else that's going on? If so, this piece may fall into the category of "Cozy Horror".
Sensuousness
Diving further into the importance of environment and atmosphere in "Cozy Horror", Cruz argues that "in this sense, the work of cozy horror literalizes the theme by portraying soothing moments of peace amidst the terror: crackling hearths, frothy tavern mugs, snuggling up in camping tents3." In this case, there is an added emphasis on "vibes" within the scary story. The reader or viewer finds a relaxing comfort in the almost ASMR-like background noises and sensations within the scene, despite the looming threat that may lurk around the corner. This may subconsciously be why so many spooky stories are set in a charming New England town in Fall. The allure of the environment provides a cultural familiarity with the promise of harvest and childhood memories of trick or treating while also playing up the changing seasons and death that is soon to follow.
Distance
Distance is also something to consider when classifying a piece of media as "Cozy Horror". In the opinion of Cruz, "the difference here is that the primary threat within the work of cozy horror is (almost) always something the audience can feel that they are in no (relatively) immediate danger of ever having to endure themselves4." This can easily be achieved by setting the story in the past, somewhere far away from where the reader/viewer currently resides, like a distant planet or secret ghostly realm, or in the far future. The feeling of dread associated with horror is less overwhelming if the danger is happening to someone else that doesn't have any chance to cross paths with you.
Fun
When reading cozy horror, many are looking for entertainment and lighthearted amusement, which may initially be in stark contrast with traditional emotions associated with horror. In this case, some readers or viewers may enjoy playful banter between characters, romantic subplots, or comedic moments in between moments of terror. A light scare or squeal can be just as, if not more enjoyable than a full on scream, and "Cozy Horror" tends to better scratch that itch for some folks than full on graphic horror.
Examples
Over the Garden Wall

Over The Garden Wall is an animated miniseries about two half-brothers, Wirt and Greg, who both travel through a mysterious forest called the Unknown to try and get back home. They meet a peculiar cast of characters along the way, including a bluebird named Beatrice, a frog with multiple names, an elderly wandering Woodsman, the pumpkin wearing residents of Pottsfield, and a creature called "The Beast" who stalks them with the intent to break their spirits and turn them into "Edelwood trees". At the end of the story, it is revealed that the boys are lost in this Limbo-like state because they fell in a pond while evading a police car after a cemetery ghost story gathering with friends on Halloween night. I personally rewatch this show every Fall for the atmospheric creeps and beautiful background art that resembles vintage halloween cards, printmaking, and New England foliage in the Fall. Overall, this show is both spooky and fun, with an added emphasis on the boys being playful and remaining positive despite their current situation in order to overcome the Beast. If any piece of media embodies "Cozy Horror", it's Over the Garden Wall.
What We Do in the Shadows

What We Do in The Shadows is one of my favorite shows of all time. Although New York City may not be cozy and atmospheric, this show has an added emphasis on comedic gore and overall fun. A lot raunchier than my first pick, What We Do in The Shadows is a mockumentary following a group of vampires that currently reside in Staten Island. The four roommates are Nandor the Relentless, a fierce former Ottoman warrier, Lazlo Craven and his wife Nadja, a ployamorous pansexual European couple who are madly in love, and Collin Robinson, a bland energy vampire with mysterious origins. They also live with their familiar, Guillermo de la Cruz who desperately wants to be turned into a vampire one day. This show is a spin off to a previous Taika Waititi film with the same name and a similar premise about a group of vampires living together in New Zealand. The gothic decor of their home and all too familiar vampire tropes are present in both the movie and the show, but all of the characters are depicted as powerful entities who are struggling to fit in with modern settings. The comfort comes when one realizes that they would be useless without their devoted familiar, Guillermo, which makes these blood sucking demons a lot less terrifying.
Coraline

Coraline is terrifying, despite being targeted towards kids. The movie is a much tamer version of Neil Gaiman's children's novella, but both the book and the movie take childhood whimsy and turn it on its head. The story stars Coraline Jones and she and her family move into the Pink Palace, a Victorian home divided into three separate living spaces for different tenants. There, she discovers a tiny door that leads to a world with the idealized version of her life. Her "Other Mother" does everything she can to grant all of Coraline's wishes, but this would come at the ultimate cost. Will Coraline make the ultimate sacrifice to keep her fantasy world?
This movie is another instant rewatch for me. I was 14 when this movie came out, but even as I was approaching my teen years, I related to young, rebellious Coraline being stuck in a state of absolute boredom with inattentive parents and living in a new sleepy town with little to no friends. Although much about her life was relatable, there was no immediate threat because the Beldam lives in an alternative world that can only be accessed through the door in the Pink Palace. As long as one wasn't a child living in that building, it is assumed that you wouldn't fall victim to the Other Mother's enchantments. In addition to this perceived distance from the threat, I would argue that a lot of what makes Coraline fall into the "Cozy Horror" category is actually its atmospheric animation. The goal of the Beldam at first is to make Coraline feel comfortable with her, and she does this by making her favorite foods, building a magical garden for her, and having the other residents of the Pink Palace perform wondrous tricks for her. As the threat sets in, these beautiful scenes warp into something much more fearsome, but the environments take up just as much importance in the plot as the main characters. They entice you into this world along with Coraline, leaving you tempted to stay as well.
Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark

I decided to use Scary Stories to Tell in the Dark as an example to show that "Cozy Horror" doesn't necessarily need to be rid of gore and violence. This supernatural horror film, released in 2019, is based on a children's collection of short horror stories by Alvin Schwartz that were first published in 1981. This work follows a group of teenage friends, who find themselves escaping a haunted house on Halloween night with a witch's journal close in hand, only to find that the witch's journal continues to write entries about its captors and all of its stories end up coming true. The illustrations alone were enough to give you nightmares, but this series also touched on frightening taboo subjects such as disfigurement, murder, and cannibalism, which some argued were inappropriate for their middle grade audience. There were quite a few attempts to ban these books, which of course only added to their allure for eager preteen readers. Watching this movie as an adult filled me with nostalgia, as I'm sure it did for many other fans of this popular franchise. It's always fun to experience these familiar stories in a new imaginative way.
The Twilight Zone

The Twilight Zone is one of the most iconic pieces of American media. It is a delightful mix of sci-fi, thriller, fantasy, and horror all contained in one anthology hosted and written by Rod Sterling. Every episode is its own contained story about uncanny events that occur to unsuspecting folks that find themselves stumbling into the "Twilight Zone". Despite the stories being engaging and commenting on a variety of social issues, The Twilight Zone still feels encapsulated in a far off place. Being shot back in 1959 completely in black and white lets the modern viewer feel some distance between themselves and the suspense in the show. It is obvious that these events took place in the past, therefore the viewer is in no current danger. Additionally, the monochromatic color palette instills feelings of nostalgia, with many of the episodes taking place in idealistic small towns or settings with limited technology. The episodes dealing with futuristic concepts are highly stylized with fashions and trends from the early 60s depicting what they assumed an advanced society would look like. These specific visuals also play into the sensuousness that is a staple for "Cozy Horror".
Push Back
The push back against "Cozy Horror" can best be summarized by an infamous The Mary Sue article: "The heart of the problem, it seems to me, is that many people see horror as an endurance contest. The more viscerally terrifying something is (the reasoning goes), the better it is at being horror5." Glassman explains even further: "Terror is the only metric by which horror is judged, and the more terrified a viewer or reader can stand to be, the better a horror fan they are. If you cover your eyes, you’ve failed at loving horror6." While "Cozy Horror" doesn’t necessarily need to be rid of blood and violence to be considered "Cozy Horror", plenty of consumers of "Cozy Horror" would prefer spooky atmospheric stories as opposed to flat out gore. However, this is all subject to personal taste.
Cora Buhlert also examines some of the most vocal critics of "Cozy Horror" in her blog post: "McNeil’s main point is that he believes that horror should make people uncomfortable and that cozy horror is therefore an oxymoron7." Some are also worried that "Cozy Horror" is a gateway for those outside of this space to infiltrate something they consider sacred. They go on to condemn the idea that "Cozy Horror" somehow taints the sanctity of the horror genre as a whole, as some may claim:
"Basically, the worry seems to be that since horror is experiencing a resurgence in popularity following the massive crash of the genre in the 1990s, more writers and bigger publishers will move into horror fiction and that horror will become sanitised and bland. Cozy horror is apparently viewed as a vanguard of this process – the first mainstream coffee shop or wine bar to open in the neighbourhood to run with the gentrification metaphor. Though personally I find the metaphor hugely problematic, because gentrification does untold harm in the real world by displacing and destroying whole neighbourhoods. People writing and publishing books some folks don’t like is in no way comparable to the real world harm done by gentrification8."
These sorts of comments can be read as gatekeeping, a practice that’s all too familiar in niche spaces, as if increasing popularity somehow tarnishes the quality of the work. Would the genre of horror become watered down by a sudden influx of new fans? Especially ones who prefer atmospheric fun tales as opposed to iconic slasher movies? Any horror fan can tell you that these sort of spooky tales have existed since the inception of horror itself. One could argue that The Call of Cthulhu and other Lovecraftian works could be classified as "Cozy Horror" due to their emphasis on description and sensuousness over direct action. Likewise, plenty of early and contemporary gothic and supernatural horror would fit under "Cozy Horror", many of which are written and read by femme horror fans.
Some also note that there is a possible gender element to the criticism of cozy horror. Within The Mary Sue article, there is a discussion about similar negative comments on YA and romance, two genres that are popular with young female audiences. However, it is important to note that there are many extreme horror fans that are women/femmes, just like how there are more masculine presenting folks that enjoy cozy horror, romance, and YA books. As a whole, women and femme presenting people tend to read more on average than any other gender demographic, so their presence in literary communities is not one to be downplayed9. While misogyny is prevalent in some horror spaces, the root of this problem is more complicated than this particular article makes it seem.
Conclusion
Now that we are living in a post-pandemic reality, it is understandable that "Cozy Horror" is becoming more popular with mainstream audiences. After undergoing years of unrelenting collective trauma, it is important for folks to find a way to regain control over their current situations. Towing the line between threatening and comfortable might reflect on our need to put ourselves back in compromising conditions, but this time triumph over them with a happy ending. It reminds me of a complicated healing process, one that folks may be undergoing consciously or subconsciously. Whatever the case, I’m in no rush to criticize something that brings people joy and a feeling of safety during these unsettling times.
All and all, there are noticeable similarities between "Cozy Horror" and Quiet Horror, a term/subgenre that’s been around for quite some time now. Both genres rely on atmospheric influence and more subtle horror mechanics, but "Cozy Horror" can take it just a step further by including comedy or romantic elements to the plot. I think "cozy" has become sort of a buzzword recently, with cozy mysteries and fantasies also popping up in popular bookstores. It is a new manifestation of a seemingly unattainable lifestyle within our current political and economic climate. People want to slow down and relax, without any unexpected stressors. What this "cozy" horror/mystery/fantasy trend really means to me is low stakes and easy reading. Not every novel has to be jammed with plot twists, action scenes, violence, or world ending consequences. Sometimes people need a break and that’s okay too.